When it comes to maintaining or upgrading the exterior of your home, few elements make as significant an impact as siding. For many Cleveland homeowners, shake siding—whether wood or vinyl—has long been a popular choice for its rustic charm and textured aesthetic. However, like all materials exposed to Cleveland’s fluctuating weather conditions, shake siding can deteriorate over time. That’s where shake siding replacement comes into play. In this blog, we’ll explore everything you need to know about shake siding replacement in Cleveland—from the benefits to the process, materials, and choosing the right contractor.
Understanding Shake Siding
Shake siding is a type of exterior cladding that mimics the appearance of traditional hand-split wooden shingles. These shakes can be made from natural cedar wood or modern synthetic materials like vinyl and fiber cement. Shake siding is prized for its rich texture, timeless appeal, and ability to add character to various architectural styles, from Cape Cods to Craftsman bungalows.
Common Shake Siding Materials:
-
Cedar Shakes: Natural, durable, and beautiful, but require regular maintenance.
-
Vinyl Shakes: Low-maintenance and cost-effective, ideal for homeowners looking for aesthetic appeal without upkeep.
-
Fiber Cement Shakes: Highly durable and resistant to pests and moisture, but more expensive and heavier to install.
Why Replace Shake Siding?
Over time, even the highest-quality shake siding will show signs of wear and tear. Cleveland’s freeze-thaw cycles, lake-effect snow, humidity, and heavy storms can accelerate the degradation of siding materials.
Common Reasons for Replacement:
-
Rotting or Warped Wood: Especially prevalent in natural cedar shakes that haven’t been regularly maintained.
-
Cracks and Breakage: Caused by hail, high winds, or physical impact.
-
Fading and Discoloration: UV rays and moisture can cause discoloration, especially in painted or stained shakes.
-
Increased Energy Bills: Old or poorly insulated siding can lead to heat loss in the winter and heat gain in the summer.
-
Pest Infestation: Termites and woodpeckers can damage natural wood shakes.
-
Curb Appeal and Resale Value: Replacing outdated siding boosts your home’s curb appeal and market value.
Benefits of Shake Siding Replacement
Replacing your old shake siding isn’t just about fixing problems—it’s also an investment in your home’s future.
Enhanced Curb Appeal
New siding revitalizes the look of your home, giving it a fresh, clean, and updated appearance. Shake siding, in particular, adds unique architectural charm that appeals to many buyers.
Improved Energy Efficiency
Modern siding products often include insulation or can be paired with a weather barrier to improve thermal performance.
Increased Home Value
According to Remodeling Magazine’s Cost vs. Value Report, siding replacement ranks high in ROI for exterior remodeling projects. Buyers often see new siding as a sign of a well-maintained property.
Reduced Maintenance
If you opt for vinyl or fiber cement shakes, you can enjoy years of low-maintenance performance without the need for staining, sealing, or painting.
Shake Siding Options for Cleveland Homes
Cleveland’s climate and architectural diversity call for shake siding solutions that are both durable and visually appealing. Here are a few popular options:
Cedar Shake Siding
Cedar is naturally resistant to rot and insects, but it does require regular maintenance. It’s ideal for historical homes or homeowners who love the authenticity of natural wood.
Vinyl Shake Siding
Modern vinyl shakes are designed to mimic real wood shakes but with none of the upkeep. They resist fading, cracking, and warping, making them a great option for Cleveland’s humid summers and cold winters.
Fiber Cement Shake Siding
This type of siding offers unmatched durability, fire resistance, and a long lifespan. While the upfront cost is higher, the long-term savings and performance often outweigh the initial investment.
The Replacement Process
If you’re planning a shake siding replacement project in Cleveland, here’s what the typical process looks like:
1. Inspection & Consultation
A professional contractor will assess the condition of your existing siding, check for underlying damage (like rot or mold), and help you choose the best material for your needs and budget.
2. Removal of Old Siding
The old shake siding will be carefully removed, and any damaged sheathing underneath will be replaced.
3. Installation of House Wrap or Insulation
A weather-resistant barrier or foam board insulation may be added to improve energy efficiency and protect your home from moisture intrusion.
4. Shake Siding Installation
New shake siding is installed with precision, whether it’s nailed, stapled, or snapped into place (depending on the material). Proper alignment and spacing are crucial for both aesthetic appeal and function.
5. Finishing Touches
Corners, trim, soffits, and fascia are installed or replaced as needed. A good contractor will clean the job site thoroughly and perform a final inspection with the homeowner.
Choosing a Siding Contractor in Cleveland
Finding the right contractor is essential for a successful shake siding replacement. Here’s what to look for:
Experience with Shake Siding
Not all siding contractors specialize in shake siding. Look for companies that have specific experience installing cedar, vinyl, or fiber cement shakes.
Local Knowledge
A Cleveland-based contractor understands the unique challenges of the local climate and will recommend materials that perform best in the area.
Licensing & Insurance
Always choose a licensed, bonded, and insured contractor to protect yourself from liability and ensure quality workmanship.
References & Reviews
Ask for references and read online reviews. Look for consistently positive feedback and examples of completed shake siding projects.
Transparent Estimates
Reputable contractors will provide detailed, written estimates that outline the scope of work, materials, timelines, and cost breakdowns.
Cost of Shake Siding Replacement in Cleveland
The total cost of shake siding replacement varies depending on the material, size of the home, complexity of the installation, and any repairs needed underneath the old siding.
Average Cost Breakdown (Per Square Foot):
-
Vinyl Shakes: $6 – $10
-
Cedar Shakes: $10 – $16
-
Fiber Cement Shakes: $12 – $18
A typical Cleveland home may require siding for 1,500 to 2,500 square feet of wall area, putting total project costs in the range of $9,000 to $35,000.
Always get multiple estimates and ask what’s included—some companies charge extra for disposal, trim, or insulation upgrades.
Final Thoughts
Shake siding replacement is a smart investment for Cleveland homeowners looking to protect, beautify, and increase the value of their homes. With the variety of materials available today, you can achieve the look of traditional wood shakes with modern durability and minimal maintenance. Whether you’re dealing with damaged siding or simply want a fresh new exterior, this project can enhance your home’s performance and appearance for years to come.
